19. Weirdmageddon: Part 1

This episode is awesome in every sense of the word.

20. The Hand That Rocks the Mabel

Not only is Gideon the first overarching villain that the show introduces, he’s also the first villain that’s legitimately scary.

21. Little Dipper

Even when Ford is out of the picture, the parallel between the two sets of twins remains as strong as ever.

22. The Last Mabelcorn

This episode is all about the dangers that come when you worship anyone, be they a taunting unicorn, a shifty triangle, or a paranormal researcher who went in too deep.

27. Weirdmageddon 2: Escape from Reality

I really, really wish I liked this more.

35. Dipper vs. Manliness

For the most part, it’s just funny.

39. Fight Fighters

My non-gaming background is only part of the reason why this episode doesn’t do it for me.